Last Updated on June 13, 2022 by Avi Steen

From a seasoned mama to another mama learning which silicone pump is for you, I want you to know something. This ultimate battle: Elvie curve vs Haakaa is something that I am not taking lightly.

I’ve researched and battled through my own experiences with a couple of “don’t cry over spilled milk” incidences. I’m here to tell you my honest thoughts on which silicone pump you should buy to help catch your letdown. Spoiler alert: Buy the Elvie Curve.

This post contains affiliate links, which means I receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using this link. Please see my disclosure for more details.

 elvie curve vs haakaa

Elvie Curve At A Glance

Elvie Curve Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Discreet (can be worn under clothes)
  • Great suction
  • Doesn’t spill easily
  • Easy to wear at night

Elvie Curve Cons

  • More expensive than other silicone pumps
  • Difficult to pour all of the milk out

Key Takeaway

The Elvie Curve is a great choice for a silicone pump because of its easy-to-use structure, portability, and discreet design. It also has great suction power and doesn’t spill easily. However, it is more expensive than other silicone pumps on the market, but for good reason.

does haakaa pump increase supply

Haakaa Pros

  • Inexpensive
  • Easy to clean
  • Can be used as a manual or hands-free pump
  • Great suction

Haakaa Cons

  • A bit awkward to carry around/use in public
  • Spills easily
  • Baby (or in my case now, toddlers) can easily knock it off (more spills)
  • Harder to place on breast and create suction

Key Takeaway

The Haakaa is a great choice for a silicone pump because it is inexpensive and easy to clean. It can also be used as a manual or hands-free pump and has great suction. However, it is a bit awkward to carry around and use in public and spills easily. It’s a great starter option.

haakaa pump stash

Why should you listen to me?

As I sit here, breastfeeding my third child, I can’t help but reflect on all the different tools and techniques I’ve used over the years. With my first child, I used a Haakaa breast pump. It was amazing how much milk I was able to collect – 210 ounces in the first month alone!

But when my second child was born, I was introduced to the Elvie Curve breast pump. And let me tell you – it is amazing! The Elvie Curve is so discreet and easy to use that I was able to continue breastfeeding for an entire year.

Now that my third child is here, I’m using the Elvie Curve once again. And this time, it’s even better than before!

What is a Silicone Breast Pump?

A silicone breast pump is a popular choice for mothers who are looking for a natural and comfortable way to express milk. Most silicone pumps are designed to fit snugly over the breast, and its suction action help to stimulate milk production while catching any leaking milk.

Some pumps can be worn discreetly under clothing, making it an ideal choice for mothers who are on the go. In addition, the silicone pumps are easy to clean and can be reused multiple times.

As a result, it is an affordable and convenient option for any mother who wants to provide the best nutrition for her baby.

There are multiple silicone pumps on the market including the Elvie Curve and the Haakaa Breast Pump. These two brands also have counterpart products, The Catch, and Ladybug, that mimic breast pads to catch heavy leakers.

Shop Now

Elvie Curve vs Haakaa

Which One Should You Buy?

Now that you know a little more about silicone breast pumps, it’s time to decide which one is right for you. If you’re looking for a pump that is easy to use, discreet, and portable, then the Elvie Curve is a perfect choice.

It’s also a great option if you want a pump that has great suction power and doesn’t spill easily. Yes, it may be more expensive but it’s well worth the price.

LATEST POSTS

Who is the Elvie Curve right for?

The Elvie Curve is great for breastfeeding mamas looking to increase their supply and catch any letdown. I also found, for me, it’s perfect if you have a strong letdown you want to relieve before feeding your baby.

The Elvie Curve is a good choice for mamas who:

-Have a strong letdown

-Want to increase their supply

-Catch any letdown

-Need relief before feeding baby

Get the Elvie Curve at its best price.

Who should avoid the Elvie Curve?

The Elvie Curve is NOT a good choice for mamas who may have oversupply, you may want to invest in (or check your insurance) for an electric pump option.

woman carrying baby while sitting on chair

Elvie Curve VS Haakaa FAQ

Is Haakaa better than Elvie Curve?

There is no easy answer when it comes to deciding between the Haakaa and Elvie Curve. Both pumps have their own set of pros and cons, so it really depends on your individual needs and preferences. If you’re looking for a pump that is easy to use and discreet, then the Elvie Curve is a great choice.

Can you use the Elvie Curve as a breast pump?

The Elvie Curve can be used as a breast pump, but it is not designed to replace a traditional electric breast pump. If you’re looking for an electric breast pump, then the Elvie Pump is a better option.

Does Haakaa lose suction over time?

The Haakaa does not lose suction over time, but the silicone cup can become stretched out after extended use. I have personally had to buy another haakaa after feeling like the suction was not as great on my first. If you notice that the pump is not as effective as it used to be, then it’s time to replace the silicone cup.

Can I use Elvie Curve while breastfeeding?

Yes, you can use the Elvie Curve while breastfeeding. The pump is designed to fit snugly over the breast, and its suction action help to stimulate milk production while catching any leaking milk right inside your bra.

Can you exclusively pump with Elvie Curve?

This depends on your individual needs. It may be difficult to fully empty your breast with a silicone pump alone, so an electric pump may be necessary.

Can you exclusively pump using Haakaa?

This depends on your individual needs. It may be difficult to fully empty your breast with a silicone pump alone, so an electric pump may be necessary.

woman in white shirt carrying baby

Does Elvie Curve leak?

The Elvie Curve may leak if it is not positioned correctly on the breast. Make sure to position the pump so that the flange is centered over your nipple, and pressed in to create suction.

Does Haakaa steal milk from baby?

No, the Haakaa will not steal milk from your baby. The pump is designed to catch any leaking milk that would otherwise be lost, so you can rest assured that your baby is getting all the nutrition they need.

Is Elvie Curve worth it?

Yes, the Elvie Curve is definitely worth the price for it’s ease of use, discreet design, and portability. If you’re looking for a pump that will give you great suction power and doesn’t spill easily, then the Elvie Curve is a great choice.

Does Haakaa decrease milk supply?

No, the Haakaa will not decrease your milk supply. The pump is designed to catch any leaking milk that would otherwise be lost.

How do I get better suction with Elvie Curve?

If you’re having trouble getting good suction with the Elvie Curve, then make sure that the flange is positioned correctly over your nipple. The pump should be pressed in to create suction, and the pump should be dry.

Conclusion

Both the Haakaa and Elvie Curve have their own set of pros and cons, but my honest opinion when it comes to which one to buy, Elvie Curve takes the cake. If you’re looking for an easy-to-use, discreet pump that is great for on-the-go, then the Elvie Curve is a great choice. The investment now is well worth it for the usage that will take place as you feed your baby great nutrition.

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap